Last week DoNotPay CEO Joshua Browder announced that the company's AI chatbot would represent a defendant in a U.S. court,Adultery Alumni Association (2018) marking the first use of artificial intelligence for this purpose. Now the experiment has been cancelled, with Browder stating he's received objections from multiple state bar associations.
"Bad news: after receiving threats from State Bar prosecutors, it seems likely they will put me in jail for 6 months if I follow through with bringing a robot lawyer into a physical courtroom," Browder tweeted on Thursday. "DoNotPay is postponing our court case and sticking to consumer rights."
This Tweet is currently unavailable. It might be loading or has been removed.
The plan had been to use DoNotPay's AI in a speeding case scheduled to be heard on Feb. 22. The chatbot would run on a smartphone, listening to what was being said in court before providing instructions to the anonymous defendant via an earpiece.
However, numerous state prosecutors did not respond well to DoNotPay's proposed stunt, writing to Browder to warn him that it would potentially be breaking the law. Specifically, Browder may be prosecuted for unauthorised practice of law, a crime which could put him behind bars for half a year in some states.
In light of this, Browder opted to pull the plug on the whole experiment rather than risk jail time.
"Even if it wouldn't happen, the threat of criminal charges was enough to give it up," Browder told NPR.
It's probably for the best. DoNotPay's legal chatbot was developed using OpenAI’s ChatGPT which, while no doubt sophisticated for an AI chatbot, still has significant flaws. Relying on it for anything of importance isn't the best idea at this stage.
SEE ALSO: The ChatGPT chatbot from OpenAI is amazing, creative, and totally wrongThis near miss with the wrong side of the law also appears to have DoNotPay reassessing its products. Previously the company offered computer-generated legal documents for a wide variety of issues, covering everything from child support payments to annulling a marriage. Now Browder has announced that DoNotPay will only deal with cases regarding consumer rights law going forward, removing all other services "effective immediately."
"Unlike courtroom drama, [consumer rights] cases can be handled online, are simple and are underserved," Browder tweeted. "I have realized that non-consumer rights legal products (e.g defamation demand letters, divorce agreements and others), which have very little usage, are a distraction."
The CEO also stated that employees are currently working 18-hour days to improve DoNotPay's user experience, which doesn't seem like something to boast about.
Though DoNotPay's AI experiment would have applied AI to a new area, it wouldn't have been the first use of artificial intelligence in a U.S. courtroom. States such as New York and California have previously used the Correctional Offender Management Profiling for Alternative Sanctions (COMPAS) AI tool to assess whether someone is likely to reoffend, taking it into account when determining bail.
Unfortunately, even this AI software is flawed. A 2016 study by ProPublica found COMPAS is more likely to falsely score Black defendants as higher risk, while also falsely marking white defendants as lower risk.
Artificial intelligence may seem like an exciting technology with many useful purposes. But some things are still best left to actual humans.
Topics Artificial Intelligence ChatGPT
Barcelona Open 2025 livestream: Watch live tennis for free
Aesthetically Speaking by Ivan Brunetti
Map Your Books, and Other News by Sadie Stein
Edward Gorey Does the Classics by Sadie Stein
What cracked the Milky Way's giant cosmic bone? Scientists think they know.
Herald the Crack of Bats by Adam Sobsey
Poets in the Workplace by Sadie Stein
Smoke by Philip Connors
Get Rid of Windows 10 Ads, Office Offers and Other Annoyances
My Bullish Heart
Best Max streaming deal: Save 20% on annual subscriptions
Corps de Ballet: An Interview with Irina Kolpakova by Yona Zeldis McDonough
Rebecca Walker, Maui, Hawaii by Matteo Pericoli
Aesthetically Speaking by Ivan Brunetti
NYT Connections hints and answers for May 2: Tips to solve 'Connections' #691.
The Best in Wikipedia Prose
Ben Lerner’s “False Spring”
Recovering Muriel Rukeyser’s Savage Coast by Rowena Kennedy
Today's Hurdle hints and answers for May 9, 2025
Date Your Characters, and Other News by Sadie Stein
China Eastern Airlines' C919 aircraft debuts at Singapore Airshow · TechNodeLuckin Coffee adjusts its RMB 9.9 beverage offer after taking profit hit · TechNodeTencent ventures into adapting console hit Elden Ring for mobile game: report · TechNodeASML forecasts 10%Black Myth: Wukong receives game license in China · TechNodeChinese tea brand Auntea Jenny hopes to list in Hong Kong · TechNodeOnePlus offers a refund for OnePlus 12R 256GB phone after inaccurate UFS 4.0 claim · TechNodeAlibaba Cloud announces second largeChina’s CCTV airs first AIBYD said to be launching cheaper Qin electric sedan amid price war · TechNodeTesla shares plunge to nineBeijing calls for “prudent” practice in EU antiAlibaba executive clarifies rumors about potential sale of Ele.me: report · TechNodeByteDance dives into multiHuawei, Xiaomi advertise in 2024 Spring Festival Gala · TechNodeDouyin joins lowCEO states enhancing “sense of crisis” is primary goal for ByteDance · TechNodeBeijing calls for “prudent” practice in EU antiTrip.com’s Q4 revenue doubles, CEO announces discontinuation of 2019 as a benchmark · TechNodeTrip.com’s Q4 revenue doubles, CEO announces discontinuation of 2019 as a benchmark · TechNode 'Righteous Gemstones' is another bracing HBO comedy by Danny McBride Twitter tests filter to bury unwanted DMs even further Huawei's foldable Mate X reportedly faces another delay Justin Bieber's selfies (and bangs) are back 'Invader Zim: Enter the Florpus' nails that Nickelodeon nostalgia: Review Why being a 'weekend warrior' is still good for your health Have you stared deeply into the Cat’s Eye Nebula? Samsung's Galaxy Note 10 is the perfect for phone for lefties Major security flaw exposes fingerprints of more than 1 million people Whole Foods employees want Amazon to sever ties with ICE Amazon claims its Rekognition software can now detect fear You can now use Google Assistant to bug your housemates to do their chores Apple might call its next phones 'iPhone 11' and 'iPhone 11 Pro' Airbus wants to have an autonomous aircraft prototype by the end of 2017 Samsung's 108 YouTube will block copyright trolls from swiping creators’ revenue Hackers can ransomware your fancy digital camera Motorola One Action is a phone that doubles as an action cam Simone Biles just made history (yes, again) with yet another awesome new move Democrats vow to skip inauguration on Twitter after latest Trump attack
1.6698s , 8224.9765625 kb
Copyright © 2025 Powered by 【Adultery Alumni Association (2018)】,New Knowledge Information Network