A Yemeni Nobel Peace Prize laureate who organized protests during the Arab Spring. The One on One Lessons Where You Learn Through Hands on CaressingVice President of the conservative Cato Institute who wrote a book titled "The Struggle to Limit Government." The former editor-in-chief of The Guardian when it was breaking news on the Edward Snowden’s leaked NSA documents.
What do the three people described here -- Tawakkol Karman, John Samples, and Alan Rusbridger -- have in common? They’re all members of Facebook’s new Oversight Board, often referred to as the platform’s “Supreme Court.”
On Wednesday, Facebookfinally unveiledthe first 20 people who will serve on the long-awaited Oversight Board. The independent board will rule over cases regarding content issues on the social network.
Since Facebook first made its plans for the independent Oversight Board public in 2018, the company had promised diversity among its members. Judging by that metric, CEO Mark Zuckerberg has lived up to the promise in a multitude of ways from gender and race to ideological diversity.
The 20 announcedmembers make up half of what will be a 40-person board. Half of those announced today are male, half are female. Collectively, the members of the board have lived in more than 27 countries and speak at least 29 different languages.
So far, the United States has the most representation on the board, with at least five members. The rest of the board spans the globe, with no other country currently having more than one representative on the board.
Daily content decisions will still be made by Facebook. The Oversight Board’s role, at least for now, is to make rulings on cases where specific content is removed from Facebook or Instagram. While it won’t be writing policy, these individual decisions from the board can certainly help shape it and provide guidance.
But, the biggest issue with the Oversight Board, however well-intentioned or diverse its membership is, is how limited in scope its powers over the social media giant are.
Yes, the Oversight Board has the ability to overrule even CEO Zuckerberg. Indeed, the board is its own independent corporate identity. The Oversight Board’s funding, however, comes from Facebook. In fact, the company itself chose the four co-chairs who in turn appoint the members of the board.
In addition, just because Zuckerberg can’t outright smack down a ruling, it doesn’t mean Facebook won’t have the final say.
Written out in the board’s own charter is a line that certainly gives Facebook carte blanche to opt out of practically any decision. Facebook says it will take action based on the Oversight Board’s decisions based on whether it’s “technically and operationally feasible.”
That’s fairly open and vague. It's also a pretty slick way of saying that none of what the Oversight Board rules is binding. If a decision from the board fundamentally changes the way an integral feature on Facebook works for the greater good, but it affects the company’s bottom line, does this wording give Facebook an out? Seems like it.
As NBC Newsalso points out, for a platform that has been criticizedfor its weak policieson misinformationand fake news, not a single person of the 20 announced on the board so far has a prominent background in disinformation.
With both the potential good and bad aspects of the Oversight Board laid out, it's far too early to deem it a failure or success. The board is expected to begin overseeing cases this summer. Then, we’ll see how this plays out.
Topics Facebook Social Media
Operation Mensch
Looking for something similar to 'The Last of Us'? We've got just the thing.
Substack launches 'private' newsletters
'Gunther's Millions' review: The worst kind of Netflix doc
Character AI reveals AvatarFX, a new AI video generator
15 gifts true fans of 'The Office' need in their lives
Taylor Swift's 'Lavender Haze' video contains Easter eggs, of course
12 gifts for your friend who loves Netflix
Best Sony deal: Save $100 on WH
Incognito mode on Chrome for Android just got a lot more useful
You won't see Elon Musk smoking weed in public again, NASA admin says
Kim Kardashian shared a family Halloween photo with a hilariously bad Photoshop
'Gunther's Millions' review: The worst kind of Netflix doc
Twitter is shutting down its CoTweets feature immediately
'The Last of Us' Season 2, episode 4: Why Ellie sings 'Take on Me'
Facebook gave Tinder and other dating apps special access to user data
12 'Hamilton' songs that kept their staying power after years of listening
Extremely useful website will show you Sephora reviews that mention crying
Is it 'Thunderbolts*' or *The New Avengers'?
Greta Thunberg let Leonardo DiCaprio take an Instagram pic with her
How to be an ally who stands with transgender peopleThis wings menu turns out to be quite the math problemElon Musk's highBuzz Aldrin is over the moon excited about the OlympicsSlack on an SNES? Engineer beams Slack messages to a decades old game.Best gifts for gamersWhy Spike Lee cast a Finnish actor as the most fanatical white supremacist in ‘BlacKkKlansman’Reddit's Olympic subreddit should be your homepageApple CEO Tim Cook comes out swinging against companies collecting your private dataDell's Latitude Rugged notebooks get slimmer and more powerfulGoogle apparently hired the Night King from GoT to pitch ChromebookHTC's blockchain phone, the Exodus 1, is now available for preWatch the moment when a 16'Wonder Woman' sequel delayedAngry at Trump's plan to kill transgender rights? Here's how to help.After petitioning by horse and cart, Uber legalised in another Aussie stateBuzz Aldrin is over the moon excited about the OlympicsHow to switch careers successfullyFord's selfThe 13 fiercest photos of Simone Biles' all Baseball player dodges broken bat to make insane barehanded play In search of meaning for the Facebook Like A Tory 'strong and stable' van overturned and, oh the irony Apple finally added a one Beware Snapchatters: Apple's iOS 11 makes it much, much easier to record snaps Apple still loves you, pro users, but that love will cost you iOS 11 will help you conserve precious iPhone storage WhatsApp adds new photo sharing features and a quick reply shortcut Ariana Grande releases new album and singles to benefit Manchester victims Elon Musk has a 'Zootopia' moment at the DMV Val Kilmer is going to thirsty tweet about 'Top Gun' until he's in the sequel Oculus installing free VR systems in nearly 100 California libraries Lyft partners with nuTonomy to bring self 'Star Wars' museum hopes fans can track down $200,000 in stolen goods 'Stranger Things' Season 2 won't have a Barb resurrection, thank goodness Nintendo's theme park is coming along nicely Morocco fossils push back the timeline on human origins 3 hidden clues in the new 'Game of Thrones' footage you may have missed Katy Perry can't find a signal on 'Witness' People really 'love' Facebook's Messenger reactions
1.6266s , 8226.1875 kb
Copyright © 2025 Powered by 【One on One Lessons Where You Learn Through Hands on Caressing】,New Knowledge Information Network